Image: Brady vs. Peyton Manning
58 Votes

Avatar forRob

First buzzed by: Rob

Brady vs. Peyton Manning

With Tom Brady returning from injury and big changes in Indy, which QB will be better? » Full Story on Y! Featured
Rob

Fairson: Jay Cutler will out-perform BOTH of these a**clowns this season!
Brady's O-line will let him down this year, and expose him for the mediocre QB he really is.
Manning will get hurt and have an off-year with less skill players to help him...mark my words.

posted Jul 9, 2009 |
-5
Reply

they man has 4 rings and hes mediocre??? your a dumb ass both these QBs will be in the hall and do great this year not sure about manning but brady will do good and jay cutler yeah ok who is he throwing the ball to??? him self??? good tight end about nothing really else and he should do good he has the lions the packers and vikings wow tough teams right there.... rob your a jerk off mark those words

posted Jul 9, 2009 |
0
Reply

I'm so glad that handsome Brady will be back! He makes watching football interesting. Like "Truck" said, he has 4 rings. He's about the best quarterback in the league. Manning, who knows? With a new coach and all, he may not go as well as in the past.

posted Jul 9, 2009 |
0
Reply

It's hard to say. Manning doesn't have the coach he once had, and Brady was taken down in the season opener against the 2-14 Chiefs in 2008. But then again, I couldn't care less about which of the two is better.

The QB I'm eyeing is the 2008 Offensive Rookie of the Year, Matt Ryan from the Atlanta Falcons, baby!!!! Look out for him in the years to come, or, heh, what the hell, you might as well look out for him him now!!!!!

posted Jul 9, 2009 |
-2
Reply

Hate to burst your bubbles guys. Manning doesn't need a coach. He is the coach. The only quarterback that can audible his own play. That is why he is such a big threats to the defense. If the def slacks off, Manning will make them pay for it.

posted Jul 9, 2009 |
0
Reply

we all know who is gona b better he proved it too many times TOM all the way he is a legend and he will do it again these r truth facts hete it or love it u know its true

posted Jul 10, 2009 |
-1
Reply

brady got 3 rings, not 4. do your research

posted Jul 10, 2009 |
+2
Reply

I hate to burst everyones bubble, but Brady is coming back from a knee injury. He will not be himself all season. But Peyton did the same thing last year and was playing better after 5 or 6 games. But he still wasnt his normal self all season. This doesnt mean that Brady is going to do terrible but it will be a damper on his performance. These type of knee injuries take one season to recover.

posted Jul 10, 2009 |
+2
Reply

I DONT REALLY CARE MUCH FO EITHER QBBUT ITS A MATTER OF TIME OF ONE OF THESE 2 BREAKS DOWN.I LIKE PM BUT TB IS PRETTY GOOD.WITH THE NEW COACH COMING IS I THINK PEYTON WILL STILL BE GOOD, BUT TOM JUST GOT OUT OF A INJURY WE GOTTA SEE IF HE IS MOBILE.LIKE I SAID ITS A MATTER OF TIME NETWEEN WHICH QB WILL BREAK DOWN.

posted Jul 10, 2009 |
+1
Reply

brady is the s*** and no one else matters, rember 2007 people your about to magic happen all over again. Long live the pats!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

posted Jul 10, 2009 |
-1
Reply

Brady is far superior to Manning. Besides the year they went 18-1, Brady never really had any WR stars to throw to. Manning has has a stable of top receivers since he has been with the Colts who all have played with him his entire career as opposed to Brady, who's WR change from year to year. Brady also has been in 4 Super Bowl with 3 Wins and 2 SB MVP's and an NFL MVP award too. He has better stats, win precentage in regular season, and playoffs, and holds some pretty impressive records: 50 TD is one season, a 21 game winning streak, and 16-0 in regular season / 18-1 overall. Manning is no slouch, but definitly 2nd to Brady. If the Pats had gone 19-0 I think Brady would be considered the best of all time.

posted Jul 11, 2009 |
0
Reply

I CANT WAIT FOR BRADY TO PLAYTHIS YEAR. GO BRADY YOUR THE MAN.AND HAVE A SAFE SEASON.

posted Jul 16, 2009 |
0
Reply
Post Comment

Want to post a comment?

Just sign in and you'll be good to go

New User? Sign Up | Sign In